Title comps

Realized prices for the same title, issue and grade across houses — different physical copies. For one specific slab, use cert provenance.

Same book, same gradecard fossil pokemon shellder #54 1st editionSame card, set and grade across sources — different physical copies. Not the same slab. For one specific slab's history use cert provenance.

Window3 yrs 5 yrs 10 yrsGraderall CGC 27 PSA 11

solid6 sales (universal label, last 5 yrs, PSA)median $26.00IQR $23.00 – $119.00Jun 6, 2026 → Aug 31, 2026Fanatics Collect, Alt · PSA32 not counted

PSA 10 2 sales · $165.00 PSA 9 n4 · $24.00

—eBay1999 POKEMON FOSSIL 1ST EDITION #54 SHELLDER PSA 71st editionPSA 7no realized priceunsold
live noweBay1999 POKEMON FOSSIL 1ST EDITION #54 SHELLDER PSA 71st editionPSA 7live — not a realized pricestarting bid $0.99
live nowFanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9live — not a realized pricecurrent bid $5.00
live noweBay1999 POKEMON FOSSIL 1ST EDITION #54 SHELLDER PSA 91st editionPSA 9live — not a realized priceasking price $50.00
live noweBay1999 POKEMON FOSSIL 1ST EDITION #54 SHELLDER PSA 81st editionPSA 8live — not a realized priceasking price $42.69
—eBay1999 POKEMON FOSSIL 1ST EDITION #54 SHELLDER PSA 81st editionPSA 8no realized priceunsold
Sep 14, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$11.00
Sep 14, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$11.00
Sep 14, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+1st editionCGC 8.5grader filter: PSA only$11.00
Sep 7, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 10 GEM MINT1st editionCGC 10grader filter: PSA only$27.00
Sep 7, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9.5 MINT+1st editionCGC 9.5grader filter: PSA only$13.00
Sep 7, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$11.00
Sep 7, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$11.00
Sep 7, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$10.00
Sep 7, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8 NM-MT1st editionCGC 8grader filter: PSA only$6.00
Sep 7, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+1st editionCGC 8.5grader filter: PSA only$8.00
Aug 31, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 PSA 9 MINT1st editionPSA 9$26.00
Aug 31, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$12.00
Aug 31, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$13.00
Aug 31, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+1st editionCGC 8.5grader filter: PSA only$7.00
Aug 31, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9.5 MINT+1st editionCGC 9.5grader filter: PSA only$13.00
Aug 10, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+1st editionCGC 8.5grader filter: PSA only$8.00
Aug 3, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 PSA 10 GEM MINT1st editionPSA 10$180.00
Aug 3, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$17.00
Aug 3, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8 NM-MT1st editionCGC 8grader filter: PSA only$6.00
Aug 3, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+1st editionCGC 8.5grader filter: PSA only$6.00
Jul 13, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9 MINT1st editionCGC 9grader filter: PSA only$13.00
Jul 13, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8.5 NM-MT+1st editionCGC 8.5grader filter: PSA only$11.00
Jul 13, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 PSA 9 MINT1st editionPSA 9$22.00
Jul 13, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 9.5 MINT+1st editionCGC 9.5grader filter: PSA only$15.00
Jun 22, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 PSA 9 MINT1st editionPSA 9$26.00
Jun 15, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 PSA 9 MINT1st editionPSA 9$21.00
Jun 15, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 10 PRISTINE1st editionCGC 10grader filter: PSA only$88.00
Jun 15, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 8 NM-MT1st editionCGC 8grader filter: PSA only$8.00
Jun 8, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 10 PRISTINE1st editionCGC 10grader filter: PSA only$94.00
Jun 8, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 10 GEM MINT1st editionCGC 10grader filter: PSA only$22.00
Jun 6, 2026Alt1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 PSA 101st editionPSA 10$150.00
May 18, 2026Fanatics Collect1999 Pokemon Fossil 1st Edition Shellder #54 CGC 10 GEM MINT1st editionCGC 10grader filter: PSA only$31.00